This week...

Manga: Elex (2.29) · Level (2.29) · m&c! (2.29) · 3L (2.29)
Anime: Fairy Tail Season 2 Weekdays, 630PM
Chrome Shelled Regios Weekdays, 10PM
Cardfight Vanguard, Sundays, 10AM
LAST EXILE -Fam, The Silver Wing-, Saturdays, 7P (same day as Japan)
(On Animax Asia; All times in WIB or UTC+07)

3.28.2007

Gakuran VS Blazers (No, these *aren't* competing teams)

(But the wins, nevertheless ^^)

I was reading an article in the April 2007 edition of about the merits of gakuran versus blazers as high school uniforms and after seeing that four five (I can't count, it seems) of the thirteen and models were characters played by Fukuyama Jun-san (when you're struggling with writer's block, you take inspiration wherever you find it), I decided to expand that list to include other (like Suzumura Ken'ichi-san and ).

Some of these bishounen charas are too totally well-known. I chose only one representative per school, and sometimes, he's not even the animanga lead *sweatdrop*

But before I get into my list, here's a quick history (translated/adapted from the Fitting Room: Gakuran Uniform vs Blazer article by Lily in the April issue of Animonster, with some additions from Japan from A to Z: Mysteries of Everyday Life Explained by James M. Vardaman, Jr. and Michiko S. Vardaman).

The history of or uniforms in Japan dates back to 1882, from the time the Education and Culture Department mandated the wearing of uniforms by all Japanese junior and senior high students. The Japanese army's sergeant combat uniform patterned after European army uniforms served as the model for the male students' uniform. It was first introduced in what is now known as Tokyo University, ostensibly to ensure student obedience and facilitate their acting as a group. The girls' uniforms were called sailor seifuku, while the uniform for boys was the gakuran or tsume-eri. The sailor seifuku uniform usually consisted of a white blouse, tie, blazer, vest and skirt, while the gakuran comprised a white shirt, tie, blazer, vest, and trousers.

The word gakuran itself comes from gaku, student and ran which means Western country. So in denotation, gakuran is a Western student's uniform. By 1886, Tokyo University required the wearing of gakuran with stiff collars and gold buttons. Customarily, the color of the gakuran is black--from top to bottom, including belts. Shoes can be loafers or sneakers. These were later customized with the addition of school badges or pins on the collar.

This model remained the norm until the 1960s when school caps was were added (and my subjects are not agreeing with their verbs, sheesh). By the 1970s, schools freed the students from the uniform constraint, but a decade later, a back to uniform trend revived--with models and colors that were considered more fashionable. The trend continued and by the early 1990s, big names in fashion got in on the act of designing school uniforms. By the mid-1990s, American-style blazers had gained a foothold but as the millennium neared its close, British-style blazers came into fashion.

Gakuran

  1. Usually black
  2. Stiff-collared, with a collar height adequate to cover the neck; the length of sleeves are shorter than the shirt worn on the inside, exposing the shirt's cuffs.
  3. Long-sleeved shirts or t-shirts may be worn with the gakuran, but the best contrast combination can be achieved with a white long-sleeved shirt
  4. Buttons (those accessories that fangirls fight tooth and nail over) march down the length of the jacket and the perfect buttons for a gakuran are gold ones

Blazers

  1. Comes in a range of colors, which is why the necktie is critical
  2. The inside shirt should be tucked into pants for neatness, especially when the blazer is unbuttoned
  3. Long-sleeved shirts in coordinating colors work best.
  4. Only two or three buttons, especially for the double-breasted model

Now for the promised lists:

Gakuran

Kippei from ep1 of Aishiteruze Baby

Kippei from Aishi Baby shows off the draw of the gakuran.

  1. Arima Souichirou ()
  2. Echizen Ryoma (Tennis no Oujisama)
  3. Hatori Yuuya ()
  4. Hoshino Yakou (Yurara no Tsuki)
  5. Katakura Kippei (Aishiteruze Baby)
  6. Kouno Tooru (Princess Princess; when he's not in his hime outfit; seiyuu Fukuyama Jun-san)
  7. Kyu (Tantei Gakuen Q)
  8. Kurosaki Ichigo ()
  9. Lelouche Lamperouge (Code Geass ~Hangyaku no Lelouch~; seiyuu Fukuyama Jun-san)
  10. Mikagami Tokiya (Flame of Recca)
  11. Minami Itsuki (Air Gear)
  12. Mutou Kazuki (Busou Renkin; seiyuu Fukuyama Jun-san)
  13. Nagoya Chiaki (Kamikaze Kaitou Jeanne)
  14. Narumi Ayumu ()
  15. Sagara Sousuke (Full Metal Panic)
  16. Sakai Yuuji (Shakugan no Shana)
  17. Sawada Shin (Gokusen)
  18. Sawamura Seiji (Midori no Hibi)
  19. Shibuya Yuuri (Kyou Kara Maoh!)
  20. Tachibana Ryouki (Hot Gimmick)
  21. Takano Kyouhei ()
  22. Tohno Shiki (Lunar Legend Tsukihime)
  23. Ukiya Shun (GateKeepers)
  24. Watanuki Kimihiro (xxxHOLiC; seiyuu Fukuyama Jun-san)
  25. Yano Motoharu ()
  26. Yasuhara Osamu ()
  27. Yuuki Asuka (Dr Rin ni Kiite Mite)

Blazer

Ryota from Soul Link ep1

Someone tell Ryota-kun from Soul Link that guns are optional.

  1. Agate Fluorite (Cluster Edge)
  2. Aizawa Ryota (Soul Link)
  3. Arou Naitou ()
  4. Garaku Yasuaki (Happy Hustle High)
  5. Itou Keita (Gakuen Heaven; seiyuu Fukuyama Jun-san)
  6. Kiriyu Zero ()
  7. Magahara Mizuki (Platinum Garden)
  8. Matsuura Yuu (Marmalade Boy)
  9. Miyagusuku Kai (Blood+)
  10. Odagiri Azusa (Hot Gimmick)
  11. Sano Izumi ()
  12. Shinpo Ichi ()
  13. Sugita Tsuyoshi ()
  14. Suou Tamaki ()
  15. Tsukimori Ren (La Corda d'Oro ~primo passo~)
  16. Yagami Light ()

Geh. My bias is totally showing... Yes, that means the probability of me making a list for characters in sailor seifuku (with the possible exceptions of Kanzaki Hitomi from Tenkuu no Escaflowne and Ed from Meine Liebe ^^) is less than one percent. A list of bishounen in cardigans and red-haired sword wielders, however... That bears contemplating *beams*

I prolly called some of these wrong. If I made mistakes in categorizing or you want to add some more characters, do leave a comment, k?

~nik who is totally at a loss where to slot in Yuki and Kyou from Fruits Basket and Wakamiya Kyou and Asamoto Soushi from Watase Yuu's Alice 19th and Zettai Kareshi respectively
花木兰

PS It occurs to me that I suffered through grade school in a sailor uniform. Could that account for why I'm not too enamored with it?

invaluable resource(s)

  • Animonster VOL97 April 2007 » Fitting Room: Gakuran Uniform vs Blazer (Text by Lily)
  • Japan from A to Z: Mysteries of Everyday Life Explained by James M. Vardaman, Jr. and Michiko S. Vardaman (© YENBOOKS)

5 veni, vidi, velcro (came, saw, got stuck):

Runesque said...

lOh yes, I remember coming across this little section in Animonster and squealing in pure fangirlish delight ^^. I love how they used Lelouch to model one of the gakurans and Tsukimori+Tsuchiura for the blazers v v v - even adding their own comments on the fashionability of each one. This straying from the usual matter-of-factness I'd like to see more of from Animonster. The doujinshi section is a good starting point.

Somewhat off-topic: Did you really wear sailor suits as a gradeschooler? If it's not encroaching too much upon private life, can I ask where you live/spent your childhood...? I mean you do read Animonster so that came as a surprise to me.

huamulan03 said...

Hello again ^^
If *I'm* not being too nosy, would like to know if you favor either uniform. I mean, you already know that for me the gakuran wins by a whit... ;)

I guess saying I wore a sailor uniform as a kid sorta gave away that I didn't attend primary school in Jakarta, huh? But I didn't attend it in Japan either. Philippines, hun. ^^

Runesque said...

Well... while each has its own merits, I guess I'll go for the gakuran since I'm very partial towards CLAMP's design and Lelouch *rawrr*. Plus, a guy tends to look taller/leaner in it. Emphasise on "tends".

Okay, I sort of assumed you were Japanese-born living in Indonesia. Schoolkids wear sailor fuku in the Philippines, do they? I didn't know that.

huamulan03 said...

Well, I go "awww" over Suzaku in uniform but you called that *rawr* on Lulu in gakuran right ^^

Actually not all Flip kids wear sailor fuku--my school was the only one I knew that had it. I don't even know if they're still using it now. It was *cough* unique at that time (not in a good way), not at all like the kewl uniforms of the other schools, which might account for the mini "trauma" (erk, sowwy for the overshare... *sweatdrop*)

yogurt said...

"By the 1970s, (Japanese) schools freed students from the uniform constraint, but a decade later a back-to-uniform trend revived...."

And in the 1990s, the exact opposite happened in a lot of U.S. schools.
In real life, the advantages and drawbacks of school uniforms in general balance out so evenly that any changes tend to lead to an eventual return to the cultural norm.

In animation and comics, however, uniforms gain an important advantage while a major real-world drawback becomes irrelevant. The advantage is that the tendency for animated characters to have only one outfit each is justified, and you no longer need to invent outfits for each and every character, including backgrounders.
The opposite holds true in live action- in a real-world present-day setting, most of the extras in a non-uniformed school can wear their own clothes. Uniform means the producers have to buy one for every kid they expect to have on set at the same time. Which leads to..

Cost, a major factor for school administrators, and a nonissue for mangaka. In addition, there's never a need to settle for a cruddy, cheap uniform- golf shirts and gakuran cost exactly the same to draw.

All that having been said, since we're talking teenage boy characters here, you could outfit them with varied individual clothes with only three model sheets- T-shirt, button shirt, hoodie; jeans, not-jeans and shorts. Mix, match and recolor as desired.

Post a Comment

When commenting, kindly leave a name, make one up, whatever. I would like to call you something other than "anonymous-san" ^^

Arigatou gozaimuchness,
Niki

Recent posts